The Role of Witness Testimony in Your San Antonio Car Accident Claim –

Car accident cases often turn into a “they said/I said” situation, even in San Antonio. Witness testimony can influence the outcome of your car accident claim with a new layer of evidence, especially when it comes to comparative negligence laws. Witnesses can provide you with unbiased accounts that clarify any ambiguity. This article aims to show the potential importance of witness testimony, how to use it, how it can impact your claim, and how to effectively incorporate it into your case.

Negligence in Texas

Texas follows what’s called a modified comparative negligence system. This allows anyone who is not more than 50% at fault for an accident to make a claim for damages. Further, the percentage of fault that you’re assigned after an accident will directly affect your compensation amount. With this in mind, a witness account can illustrate the events leading to an accident more clearly and diminish your percentage of fault.

Importance of Witness Testimony

Witness testimony in a car accident claim case can serve you in multiple ways:

1. Clarification: A witness or witnesses can be more objective than those who were injured or are fighting a claim. Their account of the accident can be clearer, without added emotion, and offer details that the involved parties could have missed or remembered incorrectly.
2. Influence Liability Determinations: The witness can either strengthen what you’ve already claimed or dispute what the other party is claiming. This can influence the determination of the percentage at fault, strengthening your case.
3. Impact on Insurance Negotiations: Insurance companies put a lot of weight on witness statements during claim evaluations. A credible witness can easily sway negotiations in your favor.
4. Support in Legal Proceedings: Should your claim end up in court, witness testimonies are evidence on your behalf. The details provided by the witness and their credibility can have a substantial impact on the decision of the judge or jury.

Gathering and Using Witness Testimony in San Antonio

Whether or not your witness testimony will help your case depends on many factors, one of which is proper gathering of statements and how you use them. 

• Immediate Collection of Witness Information: Once you make sure you and others are safe and getting needed medical treatment, try and collect information at the scene of the accident. Minimum, get the witness’s contact information including names, phone numbers, and addresses.
• Statement Gathering: You’ll want to gather statements while the accident is still fresh in their minds. It’s best to approach the witnesses as soon as possible after the accident. Delaying too long can either lead to missing details or your witness being unreachable.
• Collect Professional Statements: While you can collect witness statements, they have a greater impact if you hire a legal professional and leave it to them. They can conduct or, at minimum, oversee the process to make sure that your witness statements are thorough and accurately recorded. 
• Witness Bias: Your witnesses may have biases. You’ll need to determine what the biases are right away. A witness’s relationship to the parties involved or pre-existing opinions about the accident affects their perception, their neutrality, and how much they can actually help your case.
• Corroboration with Other Evidence: Ideally, your witness statements should support the other forms of evidence you plan on presenting. This can be traffic camera footage, police reports, and physical evidence.

Using Witness Testimony Strategically

Witnesses who have no personal stake in the claim are a top priority, especially those who had a clear, unobstructed view of the accident. The testimony of witnesses like this can give a strong foundation to your case and help establish fault and liability.

If your case ends up in court and in trial, witnesses will be cross-examined. This involves both parties questioning the witness to test their accuracy and reliability. This is where good statement gathering comes into play but also where biases can come out and hurt your case. Effective cross-examination can expose inconsistencies or biases in your witness account or the other party’s. 

Then there are two categories of witnesses: your lay witnesses and the expert witnesses. Your lay witnesses are those from the scene of the accident who can state details about what happened and who did what, and when. Your expert witnesses offer specialized knowledge on details like vehicle mechanics, medical injuries, and accident reconstruction. Your experts can provide testimony on your behalf that will explain more complex issues in ways the jury can understand and/or lend weight to liability claims. Selecting your expert witnesses is an important process.

Complications

Human Memory

Human perception and memory aren’t infallible. Witness accounts of an accident are directly impacted by their physical location, attention at the moment, and later events that could alter their memory. What this means is that two witnesses of the same event can have honest but different accounts of what happened. A professional San Antonio car accident attorney can help you find reliable witnesses for your case. 

Legal Scrutiny

Witness testimony can have a large impact on your case. Because of this, these statements will be put under rigorous scrutiny. Witnesses will be responsible for being consistent with their answers whether in deposition or at trial and will be asked to recount their details many times. What they’re looking for is discrepancies in their account. Even if they’re due to the natural infallibility of human memory rather than lies, discrepancies can hurt your case or at least eliminate a witness. An attorney can help prepare your witnesses for this scrutiny and better prepare them to deal with the stress and maintain their testimony consistently.

Practical Difficulties

Witnesses may not want to come forward. Some don’t want to get involved. Some are scared of retribution or violations of their privacy. Some don’t want the emotional burden of being involved in legal proceedings. 

Conclusion

When it comes to car accident claims in San Antonio, there’s a delicate balance between the valuable insights that a witness can provide to your case and the factors that can complicate it. It’s best to hire a legal professional to use their expertise to collect statements, determine potential biases that could hurt your case, and prepare your witnesses for any scrutiny that may come their way.

Related